2012/06/27

Solar Power - Small Scale Grid Tie Power Generation


Solar Power - Small Scale Grid Tie Power Generation
Phetz Zantua

At an alarming rate that the power crisis is creeping in our midst either by limited power generation capacity or by escalating bunker and coal prices, it is but riveting that full implementation of Renewable Act of 2008 has turned into lip service.

It has been 4 years ago when RA 9513 (Renewable Energy Act of 2008) was enacted and yet renewable energy has not yet sink in into general public consciousness. The general public is still left in the dark (pun intended) on the provisions of the law that enables them to become energy independent. All talks are concentrated on large scale commercial Renewable Energy (RE) power generation. There are no mention or public information drive that encourage small scale power generation like house grid-tie systems.

While it is a fact that FIT is still debated and to be agreed upon by major players, there is the provision of the law that is totally neglected. Section 10 of the Act stipulates Net Metering scheme that can be entered between utility provider (e.g. Meralco and consumer), but this provision is not being implemented or encourage to be "enabled."A net metering scheme will encourage house owners to install themselves with Renewable Energy (RE) power generating units such as grid-tied Solar power systems.

There is now current technology that is economically viable to be fitted in household level. There are now systems that can be specified or scaled to provide a percentage of the household demand. The system can also be scaled up to provide electricity generated by a RE source (i.e. solar panels) to even up to 100% of the household demand. 100% can be realized only by full implementation of Section 10 of the law, since in absence of clear regulations on the net metering scheme the household owner will be in trouble explaining to Meralco how come his bill has gone down to Zero consumption. What owners of grid tie solar power system can do now is size their system at a level that they will not export too much of excess electricity or dump their excess since excess exportation of surplus power will yield them nothing in return or in fact put them into trouble if local Meralco offices will treat this phenomena as tampering.

As a private citizen with an adequate know-how of the technology, I have installed in my own household a grid tie Solar panel system. We are now in the second month of operation of the system and we have now reduced our dependency on Meralco by as much as 32%. We have lowered our bill at almost half we pay on average the past year, we were able to cut down our demand from 248 kW-hr (12 month average) to 180 kW-hr (last February billing) and to 149 for March bill’s. There are days when our household demand is lower than what the system is producing, during those days we are exporting power from solar panels to the Meralco grid. The savings if equated to car (Honda City as a reference) milage is almost 96 kilometer driving without filling the tank, and if equated to greenhouse off set value, we off setted an approximate 1 tree already. At the rate of the generation we are making, we are about to off set 12-15 trees in 1 year.

System like mine is still unknown to the public and of course also unknown to Meralco. I will be willing to enter into net metering agreement with Meralco if there is clear scheme that’s been approved by the government (i.e. ERC or DOE or DTI) as stipulated by Section 10 of RA 9513.For immediate action, it is but imperative that the net metering provision of the law should be implemented to encourage small grid tie connections. Grid tie solar power will result in a distributed power generation for direct end users and enabling the system owners to export their excess power to the grid. The system owners can be compensated either by energy credits or paid by an agreed price based on the volume of their exported power. After all the Renewable Portfolio Standards (RPS, in short their energy mix) value of utility providers (i.e. by Meralco) will increase by accepting into the grid the excess power produce from household solar panels.

Since Solar panels are yet to be sold at an acceptable level to middle class families, households with Solar Panels either grid-tie or off grids, should be given incentives like 5 year suspension of realty tax, access to credits for procurement of panels from US or China and rebates for balance of system procured locally like breakers, cables, and mounting brackets.

It is only the backward thinking, lack of ingenuity and neglect of the government people that discourage the full implementation of the law for the benefit of the suffering Filipinos. And to add insult to injury, the democratization of power generation is left into big business interest who after all are behind those power projects that promote fossil (coal, bunker and diesel) fuel use.

30 comments:

  1. Hi Phetz,

    Are you using a bi-directional meter from MERALCO?

    Does it count backwards when you're exporting electricity back to the grid?

    Sunny regards,
    Rodelio
    +639178216827

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes we are using bi-directional meter.

    We have been installed with GE I-210 meter. This meter is a smart digital meter and can measure both export and import electricity.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It is very important to choose a good and high efficient grid tie inverter. I have a 1.5 kw solar grid tie system and a 400 watt off grid system with batteries to overcome brown outs. Our grid system runs in droop mode, which means that the net frequency drops when the load increases, order a grid tie inverter with the right parameter settings. A good inverter is growatt and I use the Dutch Mastervolt inverter.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Philippines are only talking about renewables but do nothing at all. No legislation concerning grid tied systems, customs that will charge you more than your initial purchase price and transport, nowhere you can go with your complaints as you get no bills from broker, while asean decided to charge only VAT on renewables. It discourages me to go ahead with promoting solar in Philippines. Look at the prices of solar panels in Philippines and than think that now panels in China are being sold for 0.6 u$/watt, good panels.
    The break even point with these prices lie within 4 years of operation while panels last at least 20 years.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  6. Hello Eastgreenfields,

    Did meralco provide you the bidirectional watt hour meter?

    My I70 GE watt hour meter spins backward but the reading spin forward even I am exporting power to Meralco.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Do those digital kWh meter count backwards when we feed in the grid. Of course those old analogue meters with a wheel do. But the new ones with the display. Actually in Europe smart meters are use which have different display for the consumed and grid supplied Kw's.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Phetz

    I am running a 1.9KW Off Grid Solar, I am thinking of shifting 1.14KW to Grid Tie to get the max benefit of the system, but my meralco watthourmeter is Model GE Type 1-70-S, is this bi-directional? will it count backwards as I export power to the grid?or do I need to ask Meralco people to change it?

    ReplyDelete
  9. To Manuelito Nazaire,

    Your decision to grid tie is very encouraging.

    I'm not familiar with the Type 1-70-S. But you can ask Meralco to change your meter into GE I-210. But be advise that the factory setting of the GE I-210 is that the RECEIVED energy (from grid tie modules) increments the DELIVERED (import energy from Meralco grid). Ask Meralco to set the meter to Received - Delivered mode of operation if they will agree.

    As of the moment, be mindful of the excess energy that you will export via the revenue meter from Meralco because instead of bill reduction, you might as well be charge of the energy you exported.

    Unfair? yes it is... that's why Philippine Net Metering Rules must be implemented as soon as possible.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  10. is their any other meter like GE-210? that can measure receive and delivered power

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There are other brands that are bi-directional (Deliver and received). Top global brands are available such as ABB, Siemens, etc... the question is does ERC accredited this brands for use in as revenue meters?

      Delete
  11. This what I send already many times to the directors of DOE and RE matters in Philippines :


    Dear Sir,


    I have already a grid tied and an off grid solar system running for about 2 years in PPC Palawan.
    We (me and an Australian partner) like already to start a solar company a.s.a.p. in the Philippines
    And we went to Paleco the Palawan electric distributor for an agreement to connect grid tied systems
    To their grid.
    I told about all your initiatives but their answer was that Palawan is an off grid system as they are not
    Connected with the Luzon grid.

    We asked them the following questions :

    1. What is your feed in tariff? They said nothing as Palawan is off grid.
    2. Smart metering to measure the feed in kW’s . (not applicable for Palawan)
    3. Inverter parameter settings like switch off and on grid frequency and voltage (not applicable for Palawan).

    I use a Ferraris (wheel type) kWh meter which turns backwards in the daytime equal to the grid supplied solar kw’s
    And get actually the same money now for my kw’s as I pay, just use their grid to accumulate the solar energy from the day time.
    And they finally told me that this is allowed as long as I do not produce more than I consume.
    But we need to implement here the legislation from your departments a.s.a.p. as this is not a sustainable solution as
    Digital kWh meters are rapidly replacing the analogue (Ferraris) meter and what can we tell our solar clients who have
    Digital meters ? There is always a possibility that you supply more than consumed when people are away and all solar
    Power goes into the grid and meter reading are lower than the month before , you have something to explain.

    We like to start as soon as possible with on and off grid solar, wind and small hydro but need feed in tariffs.

    Last week got a mail from Holland where investors are asking me for possibilities to connect very large wind mills to the
    Philippine grid. These investors want to pay themselves for the windmills, transport and erection but want a feed in contract
    With the power distributor. I told them about the situation in the Philippines which is complex.

    I imported solar items on small scale already and we paid more money on customs and warehouse storage costs than the
    Whole purchase price including the transport to the Manila north harbour.

    The Philippine renewable energy departments should implement the legislation all over the Philippines a.s.a.p..

    1. Any bad conduct of customs officials and brokers should be punished immediately.
    2. Feed in tariffs legislation for different renewable sources implemented throughout the Philippines.
    3. Clear parameter setting of inverters which will be connected to the Philippine grid.
    4. Checking and rules on quality of solar installations, most have dangerous high DC string voltages.
    5. No long procedures to obtain an licence when needed.
    6. Introduction of smart power meters (kWh) which measure consumed and reversed power supplied into the grid.
    7. When using a Ferraris power meter inform people that lower readings can be possible when consumed less than produced.
    8. A PR person within your department who answer questions about renewable power in the Philippines.

    I wrote so many renewable energy departments in the Philippines already but hardly get an answer on my mails with questions.

    Hope I will get from you this time.


    Kind regards : Koos Mulder/Electronic engineer/Palawan/Philippines.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi,

      Thank you very much for considering this blog as a good source of information on the RE situationer in the Philippines.

      Although this blog is informational and sometimes editorial we do make a disclaimer that our comments and sometimes our editorial is only our opinion on news, feature items and other articles that we quoted.

      We are honored that you approached this blog with high regards.

      Our opinion with your situation in Palawan.

      1.) Palawan is part of the SPUG or the Small Power Utilities Group of the NPC. Luzon, major islands of visayas and the whole mainland Mindanao are areas under "main" grid. Palawan, Masbate, Catanduanes, and other islands are not part of Luzon-Visayas or Mindanao grid hence SPUG. SPUG is basically the missionary side of electrification thrust of the NPC. SPUGs actually do have a grid, albeit it is small or even micro compared to the main grid.

      2.) The appropriate RA9513 chapter would be Chapter IV for Palawan being part of the SPUG,

      I think it's better to acquire a lawyer who specialize in Energy laws and consult with them RA9513 (in particular Chapter VII(h), the EPIRA law and other pertinent laws applicable. I recommend you to take legal advice specially if as you said you intended to become an RE developer in Palawan.

      We can only point you to consult NPC SPUG website for more information: http://www.spug.ph/

      As to incentive regarding FIT or returns for developing RE in missionary areas (islands) we would like you to take a look at the DOE's MISSIONARY ELECTRIFICATION DEVELOPMENT PLAN(2012 MEDP) Chapter 3 UCME Rationalization para 3.3.3 Incentives for Renewable Energy in SIIGs (reference: http://www.spug.ph/2012%20MEDP.pdf)

      Your mission and vision of providing renewables in Palawan is commendable and worth praising. At this early stage we would like to congratulate you in taking the first steps of RE development in SPUGs. We will watch out for your endeavor and success in Palawan and hope that some day we would take some lessons from you.

      Mabuhay po kayo!

      Delete
  12. Thanks for your reply with very useful information.Till this year I was working as an electrical/electronic engineer on dredging vessels all over the globe.I am retired now and like to transfer my knowledge to the renewable energy sector and train Philippine engineers. It is very important that the people understand their systems and can trouble shoot on systems. i was in an off off grid barangay Port Barton Palawan and the people have 12 hours electric power from a centralized generator paying 40 pesos/kW,this is really incredible and I informed the people about the possibilities of solar energy. Renewable power sources have higher up front costs but need free sunshine and no fossil fuels. The Malampaya funds should be used for these projects but unfortunately this is not the case.

    rgds : Koos.

    ReplyDelete
  13. eastgreenfiels... did you ask meralco to change the setiing of your ge i210 to delivered minus received configuration... did they agree?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi,

      No we didn't.

      Our meter is already the GE I-210 when we moved-in.

      Delete
  14. had meeting with Paleco's director, asked her how these GE meters are commissioned. showed her the data sheet, she said delivered only. Asked her or she is willing to change settings when we have a client who wants an on grid system, She would think about this. Palawan is a SPUG and not implemented netmetering as Luzon did.We opened Solar Power house and have many different grid tied inverters like SMA, Effekta, Growatt, etc.., also are the first with full hybrid inverters these can feed back in the grid and supply output during brown outs.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi,

      It would be good if they consider just setting it on Delivered minus Received... no hassle to every one.

      You have a nice set up... just keep it going. Maybe it's a worth a try to ask someone from media to feature your home... these days saving and generating own power is a hot topic.

      Keep it up!

      Delete
  15. I have a few grid tie inverters on stock, like Effekta, Aerosharp, Gin Long, Lactronics but these came from a 50Hz country, we reconfigured SMA and Solar power to our grid operational bandwidth. Palawan is a SPUG operating in droop mode, the frequency drops with increasing load. The mentioned inverters have an operational bandwidth of 180 - 280Vac and 59.5-60.5Hz. This is too small for Palawan grid and will stay in FAC alarm during most of the day when freq. moves outside the freq. operational bandwidth.My question is does Luzon grid operate in isochrone mode, steady frequency? When not what is the freq. droop? and high and low limit of Luzon's grid frequency?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We have not measured per recommended procedures in obtaining the actual frequency of the Luzon grid. But we assume that it follows the -+5% range.

      Out micro grid tie inverters are working just fine, so we assume that the frequency in Luzon grid is stable.

      Delete
  16. The GE digital I210 meter is set at the most worst mode, namely received + supplied, tested the meter today with our grid tied system in our new solar shop. Now we pay for or own Kw's to Paleco and they resell the kW's, does not make sense for our solar business where we invested heavily in panels and grid tie inverters.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hello Eastgreenfields,

    I like to have a SOLAR power for my house, how/where do i start?

    Thanks,

    Jack

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Jack,

      First off, you need to know your daily load (demand). To do this look at your Meralco Bill, check out the last 12 months average. Divide this into 30 days so that you will know the daily demand.

      Now, you need to establish your demand profile... make an estimate from your daily demand how much is used during daytime, nigh time and overnight. Make a sensible guess, 40% day time, 40% night time and 20% overnight? The load profile is important because your payback period depends on this information...

      For technical queries send us you clarifications by email: inquiry@eastgreenfields.com

      We would be very glad to send you technical data and estimated system calculation.

      Delete
  18. Hello, Jack my email address is jacobusmulder@gmail.com, communication is easier by sending direct mail to me. First where are you located? some parts of Philippines implemented netmetering already and have a feed in tariff. Here in Palawan not yet, A grid tied solar system is very simple and consists of solar panels and a grid tied inverter, two wires with a dc voltage going in the inverter and comes out as AC and is connected to the utility grid, the inverter lift the AC voltage a little and now solar energy flows to your house and when all your consumers are fed, the excess energy will flow into the public grid. An analogue power meter will turn backwards and will count down every kilowatt your solar system pumps into the grid, I have made a document a will publish that later on east green fields. We have a shop in Puerto Princesa and sell German solar panels and only gooed TUV tested inverters with good MPPT and efficiency. Many cheap inverters sold on Sulit have bad MPPT system (maximum power point tracking) this works with an algorithm (P=UXI)and takes care that always the maximum power is taken from your solar system, also the efficiency is important as many inverters become very hot which is energy you want to be pumped in the grid. Efficiency is the output AC power / DC solar input power X 100%.

    ReplyDelete
  19. What is a grid tied solar system? What it can and can’t do.
    Australian Solar Power House
    Corner BM Rd beside KIAmotors.
    koos@solarpowerhouse.ph
    Grid tied system principle Mobile: 09156551604


    A grid tied solar system converts solar power through an inverter (DC/AC) and supplies it into the grid.
    First, it will supply your electrical appliances in your home but when this solar power exceeds total the power demand of your appliances the excess energy will be supplied into the utility grid.
    Example: your solar system produces 2Kw/hour but your house only needs 1 kW/hour then 1 kW will be fed into the utility grid. Now it depends what kind of power meter you have installed, an old fashioned analogue power meter (type with turning wheel) will spin backward and counts down 1 Kw which you supplied to Paleco. However when you own a digital power meter it depends how this meter is commissioned as it can be configured on different ways, the right way is the bi-directional measurement and is received minus supplied.
    Just tell us the average monthly Paleco bill and how much you like to reduce this bill and we will calculate the required solar system for you including a quotation for the system.
    The power warranty on the panels is 25 years and our system calculation will show how much money you will save on your Paleco bill over one year. When you divide the total cost of your system by the yearly savings you will get the break even years. This is the time that the system has paid itself completely back and the years after, this system will provide you with free electricity. We calculate with current Kw price of 11 pesos/kW but this price will only go up as fossil fuels will become more and more expensive over the years and break even will be reached on an earlier date.
    A grid tied system can’t power up your home during brown outs and it will disconnect from the grid immediately when grid is out of the inverters operational limits. When this is also required you need a full hybrid inverter.
    For the time Palawan is not yet subjected to feed in tariff legislation which is already active in Luzon, the owner of a grid tied solar system should not produce more green solar power then consumed. It is expected that Palawan will implement the feed in tariff within 2 years and will be paid for your excess produced Kw’s.
    If you have any questions, feel free to ask : Koos Mulder/Technical manager/Power House.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Does anybody know how to re-program GE-I210 Power meters, one need Meter Mate software according the info i got from the internet. Our meter are programmed received + supplied which is the worst setting for our business.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Too bad i was disappointed with this meter i210. Need to operate my grid tie inverter to match the minimum load. So not.to export electricity and charge back to me.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Grid tie inverters work with MPPT algoritm (P=UXI) and will dump maximum available solar (electrical) energy to the grid so not possible, you can buy a full hybrid inverter where excess power will be stored in batteries and be released to the grid after sunset.

    ReplyDelete